One Hundred Seventy-Seven

Frequently, I will allow someone whose perspectives differ radically from mine—even when I believe their perspectives are biased and immoral and fundamentally wrong—to make their case without allowing myself to automatically reject their arguments. Usually, I find their arguments weak and unpersuasive. Occasionally, though, my mind will not be changed about the position on the issue, but about the immorality and bias I assigned to the person making the case.

So it was today, when I read an impassioned argument that the Confederate flag should not be “thrown into the wastebin of history.” Though I still believe the Confederate flag is a symbol of hatred, I believe it is not always a symbol of hatred. For some, it really is a symbol of heritage. That notwithstanding, I have not changed my position on the flag; it should be preserved in museums and not in homes or in public buildings. But we should not ban it, any more than we should ban books. We should feel free to condemn it and the hatred associated with it. But we should take in account those who want and need a symbol of their heritage and help them identify other symbols that do not carry with them the pain that flag inflicts on others.

About John Swinburn

"Love not what you are but what you may become."― Miguel de Cervantes
This entry was posted in Ruminations. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to One Hundred Seventy-Seven

  1. I’m afraid it was an email from an acquaintance who’d would rather it remain between the two of us.

  2. Holly Forrest says:

    I’d be curious to read the “impassioned argument” – is it available on line?

I wish you would tell me what you think about this post...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.